Does Hamas’s Use of Human Shields Change the IDF’s Proportionality Test?
Israel’s Foreign Ministry says the IDF stays bound to mitigate civilian harm, and places primary responsibility on Hamas’s use of human shields.
What the IDF, the Military Advocate General’s Corps and the Israel Police publish about their own conduct, and the thresholds that produced the counts.
Israel’s Foreign Ministry says the IDF stays bound to mitigate civilian harm, and places primary responsibility on Hamas’s use of human shields.
A 2026 Knesset law names sexual crimes among the acts of 7 October 2023. The Foreign Ministry’s statements, dated, and the count no Israeli body publishes.
The IDF stated in February 2024 that more than $150 million went from Iran to Hamas from 2014 to 2020. Israel’s 7 October inquiries name no Iranian role.
Israel’s Foreign Ministry named war crimes and crimes against humanity in 2023. A 2026 Knesset law adds crimes against the Jewish people.
Israel’s Foreign Ministry states there is “good cause to be doubtful” about Gaza’s casualty figures. Israel’s own 2014 count was 2,125 deaths.
The Israel Prison Service held 6,762 Judea and Samaria residents on security grounds at the end of October 2025, 3,273 of them in administrative detention.
Israel’s National Insurance Institute counts 36 civilians killed in the 2026 Iran war and 35 in June 2025. The IDF gives no fallen count for either.
The IDF counts 973 soldiers fallen since 7 October 2023 whose names are cleared for publication, 472 of them since the Gaza ground manoeuvre began.
1,266 Haredi men enlisted in the IDF in 2022, on the IDF’s own count. It gives no figure for 2023 or 2024 and no count of Haredi men serving.
Druze conscription stood at about 78% in June 2023 on the Defence Ministry’s figure. No Israeli body publishes a count of Druze soldiers serving.
Israeli law makes women aged 18 to 26 liable for call-up. In 2020 to 2022, 54.6% to 55.5% enlisted; religious declaration exempted 37.1% in 2022.
A building can be a military objective by its nature, location, purpose or use, Israel’s Foreign Ministry stated on 2 November 2023.
The IDF stated on 14 September 2026 that no Gaza strike it planned or approved anticipated 500 civilian deaths, and that people, not AI, approve strikes.
Over 15 million texts, over 12 million pre-recorded calls and over 4.5 million leaflets to 8 December 2023, on the Foreign Ministry’s count of Israel’s own.
The IDF stated on 29 February 2024 it had eliminated over 13,000 people it calls terrorists in Gaza; later counts cover separate periods.
IDF pages have carried aborted-strike video since 11 March 2012; the IDF released Gaza footage on 18 December 2023 and 7 September 2026.
The IDF answers no: it says Habsora and Lavender assist analysts, a human identifies each target, and operational commanders approve strikes.
No Israeli publication read here sets a number. The Foreign Ministry says excessive harm is not measured in absolute numbers, and the IDF assesses each strike.
IDF footage supplied to IsraelFact shows 7 strikes called off, 1 held and 10 diverted in 18 clips dated 4 April 2024 to 12 July 2026.
Israel’s Foreign Ministry states IDF legal opinions are binding on individual attacks; a senior commander then approves, suspends or aborts.
The Israel Prison Service counted 1,477 Gaza residents held on security grounds at the end of December 2025, of them 1,189 as unlawful combatants.
Israel’s own statement of its objectives, with the hostage counts attached: 207 returned, 48 remaining, on the Foreign Ministry’s count of September 2025.
The IDF’s expert team named 6 central factors for the 7 October failure, and the Israel Security Agency dates detection of the plans to 2018 and 2022.
Decision 3396, adopted 9 October 2025: a ceasefire on adoption, 48 hostages in 72 hours, 250 prisoners and 1,722 Gaza detainees.
Israel’s bodies publish investigation counts, thresholds and a judicial proportionality test. No Israeli body publishes a strike-level assessment.
The Israel Defense Forces counts approximately 7,600 strikes across Iran in its live update of 13 March 2026, its own running total.
About 3.2 million residents live in areas at risk, on the State Comptroller’s 2022 audit of preparedness for hazardous materials damage in combat.
Israel’s State Comptroller recorded in March 2018 that IDF international-law training was conducted, and what the training instructions did not cover.
68 of 5,356 final decisions by Israel’s Police Investigations Department in 2021 ended in a criminal indictment, on the State Comptroller’s audit.
About 3 years and 5 months from Turkel’s second report in February 2013 to the government decision of 3 July 2016, on the State Comptroller’s audit.
What Israel’s own bodies publish: the IDF ethical code, stated precautions, 74 investigations opened, and COGAT’s recorded aid tonnages.
The Military Advocate General’s Corps reported 74 criminal investigations opened as at 3 August 2024, on its own count, under a reasonable-suspicion standard.