Does Israel Trust the Gaza Health Ministry’s Casualty Figures?
Israel’s Foreign Ministry states there is “good cause to be doubtful” about Gaza’s casualty figures. Israel’s own 2014 count was 2,125 deaths.

One of 10 questions Israel’s Foreign Ministry answered on the Gaza war in mid-December 2023 concerned civilian casualties, and its answer states that “there is good cause to be doubtful about the casualty figures coming out of Gaza.” That is the Foreign Ministry’s own stated position. The Ministry states that the figures come from “Hamas’s Ministry of Health or other Hamas authorities”. The last Israeli total of Gaza deaths on this page is 2,125 Palestinians killed in 2014, the Foreign Ministry’s own count, which the State Comptroller recorded in 2018.
| Figure | What it counts | Who published it | Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2,125 | Palestinians killed in the Gaza Strip during Operation Protective Edge, the Foreign Ministry’s own count, relayed by the State Comptroller | Ministry of Foreign Affairs | 2014 |
| About 11,000 | Palestinians wounded in the same operation | Palestinian bodies and international organisations, as attributed by the State Comptroller | 2014 |
| Over 13,000 | People the IDF describes as terrorists it eliminated in Gaza, the IDF’s own count and a floor | Israel Defense Forces | 7 October 2023 to 29 February 2024 |
| No figure | A total of Gaza deaths, or a civilian count, for the war that began in October 2023 | None of the Israeli bodies cited on this page | October 2023 onward |
The Foreign Ministry states Gaza’s figures come from Hamas authorities
Israel’s Foreign Ministry stated in mid-December 2023 that every Gaza casualty statistic, including those the UN reports, comes from Hamas authorities. This is the Foreign Ministry’s own stated position, published in English and republished by the IDF under the line “From the Ministry of Foreign Affairs”. The Ministry’s full sentence reads: “All these statistics, including those reported by the UN and humanitarian agencies, come from Hamas’s Ministry of Health or other Hamas authorities which cannot be seen as a reliable reference”.
| Element | The Foreign Ministry’s wording |
|---|---|
| Its conclusion | “there is good cause to be doubtful about the casualty figures coming out of Gaza” |
| Which figures it covers | “All these statistics, including those reported by the UN and humanitarian agencies” |
| Where it says they originate | “Hamas’s Ministry of Health or other Hamas authorities” |
| Its assessment of that origin | “cannot be seen as a reliable reference” |
Source: Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, “The War Against Hamas: Answering Your Most Pressing Questions”, as at mid-December 2023.
The same document states, in its answer on proportionality, that “An overall casualty figure does not on its own indicate unlawfulness.”
Gaza’s figures do not disclose militant deaths, the Foreign Ministry states
The Foreign Ministry states that the Hamas authorities producing Gaza’s figures “do not disclose information about militant deaths.” It also states: “Nor does Hamas disclose which casualties are the result of its own actions, or the actions of other armed groups, such as failed rocket launches”. Both are the Foreign Ministry’s own stated position, as at mid-December 2023, on what the totals leave out.
| What the Ministry says is not disclosed | The Foreign Ministry’s wording |
|---|---|
| How many of the dead were militants | “do not disclose information about militant deaths” |
| Deaths resulting from Hamas’s own actions | “which casualties are the result of its own actions” |
| Deaths resulting from other armed groups | “or the actions of other armed groups, such as failed rocket launches” |
Source: Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, “The War Against Hamas: Answering Your Most Pressing Questions”, as at mid-December 2023.
The passage describes what the figures do not disclose. It gives no number of militant deaths and no number of deaths from failed rocket launches.
The Ministry says OCHA-cited reports listed women and children above totals
The Foreign Ministry states that reports cited by UN OCHA appeared on some days to list more women and children killed than total fatalities. In the Ministry’s words, those reports “raise additional questions of distortion and misrepresentation, including by seeming to claim on certain days that more women and children have been killed than the total number of fatalities listed”. This is the Foreign Ministry’s own stated position, published in mid-December 2023.
- The reports referred to: those “cited by UN OCHA”, in the Ministry’s wording.
- The days concerned: “certain days”, with no dates given in the document.
- The figures for those days: none given in the document, either for women and children or for total fatalities.
The Ministry’s characterisation of the reports is quoted as published. The document does not identify the days or print the figures it refers to.
Israel’s Foreign Ministry counted 2,125 Gaza deaths in the 2014 operation
Israel has published its own Gaza death total before: 2,125 Palestinians killed in the Gaza Strip during Operation Protective Edge in 2014, on figures published by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The State Comptroller recorded that count in a March 2018 special report to the Knesset auditing the IDF’s conduct under international law. The 2,125 is the Foreign Ministry’s own count; the Comptroller relays it and does not measure it.
| Figure | What it counts | Attributed to | Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2,125 | Palestinians killed in the Gaza Strip, the Foreign Ministry’s own count | Ministry of Foreign Affairs | 2014 operation |
| About 11,000 | Palestinians wounded | Palestinian bodies and international organisations | 2014 operation |
| About 10,300 | Houses destroyed outright | Palestinian bodies and international organisations | 2014 operation |
| About 5,800 | Houses damaged beyond habitation | Palestinian bodies and international organisations | 2014 operation |
Source: State Comptroller of Israel, special report on Operation Protective Edge, March 2018, in Hebrew.
The deaths and the wounded come from different bodies in the Comptroller’s report, and the report does not combine them.
No Israeli body here publishes its own Gaza death total since 2023
None of the Israeli publications cited on this page gives a total of Gaza deaths, or a civilian count, for the war that began in October 2023. The IDF Spokesperson stated on 29 February 2024 that the IDF had eliminated “over 13,000” people it describes as terrorists in Gaza since the war began. That is the IDF’s own count, a floor, and a count of those the IDF classifies as combatants, not of all deaths; it is covered in full in the IDF’s count of Hamas fighters killed.
| What a reader might look for | What the Israeli publications here give | Period |
|---|---|---|
| People the IDF describes as terrorists eliminated in Gaza | Over 13,000, the IDF’s own count | To 29 February 2024 |
| Total Gaza deaths | No figure | October 2023 onward |
| Civilian deaths in Gaza | No figure | October 2023 onward |
No Israeli body cited here publishes the Gaza Ministry of Health’s total as its own figure.
Which figures here may not be added or compared?
- The 2,125 is the Foreign Ministry’s own count of deaths in the 2014 operation; the about 11,000 wounded come from Palestinian bodies and international organisations. They may not be combined.
- The over 13,000 is the IDF’s own count, a floor, of people it describes as terrorists eliminated in Gaza to 29 February 2024. It is not a total of deaths and may not be compared with the 2014 total, which covers a different operation and a different universe.
- The Foreign Ministry’s statements on Gaza’s figures are its own stated position as at mid-December 2023, quoted as published.
Questions readers ask
Does Israel say UN casualty figures for Gaza come from a separate source?
No. The Foreign Ministry stated in mid-December 2023 that “All these statistics, including those reported by the UN and humanitarian agencies, come from Hamas’s Ministry of Health or other Hamas authorities”. That is the Ministry’s own stated position.
Do Gaza’s casualty figures separate fighters from civilians?
The Foreign Ministry stated that the Hamas authorities producing the figures “do not disclose information about militant deaths.” The Ministry, in its own stated position, gives no count of militant deaths in that document.
Does Israel say some Gaza deaths came from failed rocket launches?
The Foreign Ministry stated that Hamas does not disclose “which casualties are the result of its own actions, or the actions of other armed groups, such as failed rocket launches”. The Ministry’s own document gives no number for such deaths.
On which days did reports list more women and children than total deaths?
The Foreign Ministry stated that reports cited by UN OCHA seemed to do so “on certain days”. Its own document names no dates and gives no figures for those days.
Does Israel say a high death toll shows a strike was unlawful?
The Foreign Ministry stated, as its own position, that “An overall casualty figure does not on its own indicate unlawfulness.” It states that proportionality is assessed “for every individual attack”.
Where was the Foreign Ministry’s statement on Gaza casualties published?
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs published it in “The War Against Hamas: Answering Your Most Pressing Questions”, which the IDF republished on 15 December 2023 as “From the Ministry of Foreign Affairs”. The Ministry answered 10 questions in it.
How many Palestinians did Israel count as killed in Gaza in 2014?
The State Comptroller recorded 2,125 Palestinians killed in the Gaza Strip during Operation Protective Edge, on figures published by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. It is the Foreign Ministry’s own count.
How many Palestinians were wounded in Gaza in 2014?
The State Comptroller recorded about 11,000 Palestinians wounded, attributing the figure to Palestinian bodies and international organisations. It is not combined with the Foreign Ministry’s death count.
How many homes were destroyed in Gaza in 2014?
The State Comptroller recorded about 10,300 houses destroyed outright and about 5,800 damaged beyond habitation in the 2014 operation. The report attributes both figures to Palestinian bodies and international organisations.
Which Israeli body audited the 2014 Gaza operation?
The State Comptroller published a special report in March 2018, in Hebrew, auditing the IDF and the political echelon under international law. It reported to the Knesset and relayed the casualty figures rather than measuring them.
How many people does the IDF say it killed in Gaza by February 2024?
The IDF Spokesperson stated on 29 February 2024 that the IDF had eliminated “over 13,000” people it describes as terrorists in Gaza since the war began. That is the IDF’s own count, and a floor.
Does the IDF’s 13,000 include civilians?
The Israel Defense Forces stated the figure as a count of people it describes as terrorists eliminated, its own classification. It is not a count of all deaths in Gaza.
Has Israel published a civilian death count for the Gaza war since 2023?
None of the Israeli publications cited here gives one. The Foreign Ministry stated its doubts about Gaza’s figures in mid-December 2023, and the IDF Spokesperson stated a combatant count, its own, in February 2024; neither gives a civilian total.
Sources
- Israel Defense Forces, 2024. Press Briefing by IDF Spokesperson, Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, February 29th, 2024. IDF Israel at War briefings. https://www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/israel-at-war/briefings-by-idf-spokesperson-bg-effie-defrin/february-24-press-briefings/press-briefing-by-idf-spokesperson-rear-admiral-daniel-hagari-february-29th-2024/. Official or primary record, a party’s own count.
- Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2023. The War Against Hamas: Answering Your Most Pressing Questions. Republished by the IDF as “From the Ministry of Foreign Affairs”, 15 December 2023. https://m.www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/israel-at-war/all-articles/the-war-against-hamas-answering-your-most-pressing-questions. Official or primary record, a party’s own stated position.
- State Comptroller of Israel, 2018. Operation Protective Edge: IDF Activity in Aspects of International Law, and the Examination and Control Mechanisms of the Civilian and Military Echelons. Special report, March 2018, in Hebrew. https://library.mevaker.gov.il/sites/DigitalLibrary/Documents/special/2018-03-TsukEitan-HE/2018-03-TsukEitan-Heb-FullReport.pdf. Official or primary record.


