Is Israel Obliged to Let Palestinian Refugees Return?
Israel’s Foreign Ministry stated in 2007 that no claim of return exists in international law. A 2001 law requires a Knesset majority for any return.

In November 2007 the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated, as Israel’s own legal position, that on a Palestinian “claim of return” “no such claim exists under general international law, the relevant UN resolutions or the agreements between Israel and its Arab neighbors.” Since 2001, Israeli statute has barred the return of refugees to Israel’s territory without the approval of a majority of the Members of the Knesset. The same statute allows refugee residence permits for humanitarian reasons only. Oslo II, signed by Israel and the PLO in 1995, lists refugees among the issues for permanent status negotiations and preserves each side’s position.
| Figure | What it counts | Who published it | Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section 2 | Return of refugees to Israel’s territory requires approval of a majority of the Members of the Knesset (unofficial translation) | Knesset, statute | Passed 1 January 2001 |
| 1948 and 1967 | Displacements named in the statute’s definition of a refugee, which also covers “a member of his family” | Knesset, statute | Passed 1 January 2001 |
| Section 3 | Refugee residence permits “for humanitarian reasons only”, under rules set by the Minister of the Interior | Knesset, statute | Passed 1 January 2001 |
| 4 May 1996 | Latest start date the text set for permanent status talks, whose agenda lists refugees | Israel and the PLO, Oslo II, text published by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs | Signed 28 September 1995 |
| About 95% | Share of the population then living in Israel, about 1.5 million people, who acquired citizenship automatically, on the Ministry’s own account from 1952 press reports | Ministry of Justice of Israel | 14 July 1952 |
| 1 March 1952 | Deadline for registration as a resident, 1 of 3 conditions for automatic citizenship | Ministry of Justice of Israel | 1948 to 1952 |
The Foreign Ministry states no right of return exists in international law
The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated in November 2007 that no Palestinian claim of return exists in international law. The text is Israel’s own stated legal position, published in a question-and-answer paper the Ministry keeps online for historical reference. It takes Resolution 194 and the human rights treaties in turn.
| Subject | The Ministry’s text, November 2007 |
|---|---|
| International law generally | “no such claim exists under general international law, the relevant UN resolutions or the agreements between Israel and its Arab neighbors.” |
| General Assembly resolutions | “the General Assembly is not a law-making body and General Assembly resolutions on political matters do not create legally binding obligations.” |
| Resolution 194, paragraph 11 | “That paragraph does not contain a single reference to any rights, but rather merely recommends that refugees should be permitted to return.” |
| Human rights treaties | The principle of return “only deals with individuals (not an entire people) and as a rule, governments have limited the right to reenter a state to nationals of that state.” |
| Who is counted a refugee | Under UNRWA’s definition, in the Ministry’s words, “all the generations of descendants of the original Palestinian refugees are also considered refugees.” |
Source: Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Israel, the Conflict and Peace: Answers to frequently asked questions, November 2007. Israel’s own stated position.
The Ministry’s heading uses the phrase “claim of return”, not “right of return”, and its terms are kept inside quotation marks here.
Section 2 of the 2001 law requires a Knesset majority for return
Section 2 of the Entrenchment of the Rejection of the Right of Return Law, 5761-2001, bars the return of refugees to the territory of the State of Israel except with the approval of a majority of the Members of the Knesset. The Knesset passed it on 1 January 2001 and published it in Sefer HaChukim 1772 on 10 January 2001. It is Israel’s own statutory rule, and an ordinary law rather than a Basic Law, despite “entrenchment” in its title.
| Section | Provision, unofficial translation from the Hebrew |
|---|---|
| 1 | A refugee is a person who left the borders of the State of Israel because of war and is not an Israeli citizen, “including the 1967 displaced and the 1948 refugees, or a member of his family” |
| 2 | Refugees shall not be returned to the territory of the State of Israel except with the approval of a majority of the Members of the Knesset |
| 4 | The Government of Israel shall not undertake or enter into an agreement contradicting this law |
| 5 | The law does not apply to anyone covered by the Law of Return, 5710-1950 |
Source: Knesset, Entrenchment of the Rejection of the Right of Return Law, 5761-2001, Sefer HaChukim 1772, p. 116.
The Entrenchment Law states no number or quota for return. Its definition reaches both 1948 and 1967 and extends to family members.
Oslo II Article XXXI leaves refugees to permanent status negotiations
The Oslo II Agreement states in Article XXXI(5) that permanent status negotiations “shall cover remaining issues, including: Jerusalem, refugees, settlements, security arrangements, borders”. Israel and the PLO signed it in Washington on 28 September 1995. The text set 4 May 1996 as the latest date for those negotiations to begin. The instrument does not record what followed.
| Article | Text |
|---|---|
| XXXI(5) | Negotiations “shall commence as soon as possible, but not later than May 4, 1996” and cover issues including “refugees” |
| XXXI(6) | “Neither Party shall be deemed, by virtue of having entered into this Agreement, to have renounced or waived any of its existing rights, claims or positions.” |
| XVII(1) | The Council’s jurisdiction excludes “Jerusalem, settlements, specified military locations, Palestinian refugees, borders, foreign relations and Israelis.” |
Source: Israel and the PLO, The Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (Oslo II), 1995, English text as published by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, a party to it.
The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated in November 2007, as Israel’s own position, that the two sides had agreed the question of refugees “could be considered as part of a permanent settlement between the sides. Israel stands by this commitment.”
Section 3 permits refugee residence on humanitarian grounds only
The Entrenchment Law states in section 3 that the Minister of the Interior may set rules for residence permits for refugees “for humanitarian reasons only” (unofficial translation from the Hebrew). The rules require the Defence Minister’s consent and the approval of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defence Committee. This is Israel’s own statutory route, and it provides residence, while citizenship sits under a separate statute, the Citizenship Law, 5712-1952.
The Ministry of Justice of Israel records, in its own 2019 account of the Citizenship Law, that automatic citizenship on 14 July 1952 required 3 conditions together:
- Registration as a resident under the Residents Registry Ordinance by 1 March 1952
- Being an Israeli resident
- Having been in Israel, or having entered it lawfully, between the establishment of the State and 14 July 1952
The Ministry records that the third condition was contested during enactment as preventing part of the Arab population from acquiring citizenship. The argument turned on people who left during or before the 1948 war and returned unlawfully. The Supreme Court construed the condition in HCJ 112/52 Khalaf v Minister of the Interior and HCJ 112/53 Nakara v Minister of the Interior, both in 1953. On the Ministry’s account, the government stated it did not intend to strip citizenship from a large group among the Arab population. The law’s 4 routes to citizenship are set out separately.
No Israeli body publishes a count of section 3 refugee permits
No Israeli body publishes a count of rules set or residence permits issued under section 3 of the 2001 law. The statute creates the permit, and no ministry or committee publishes its own count of the permit’s use.
- Ministry of the Interior, whose minister sets the rules: no published count of rules set or permits issued
- Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defence Committee, which approves the rules: no published count of approvals
- Population and Immigration Authority: no published count of section 3 permits
Every translation here from the Hebrew is unofficial
- The 2001 law and the Ministry of Justice’s 2019 account are Hebrew texts, and every English rendering of them here is unofficial.
- The Foreign Ministry text is Israel’s own stated legal position, dated November 2007. The Ministry notes a December 2009 edition and keeps the 2007 text online for historical reference.
- Oslo II is a bilateral instrument of Israel and the PLO, quoted in the English text published by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
- The 95% and the 1.5 million are the Ministry of Justice’s own figures, drawn from 1952 press reports, and are not a Central Bureau of Statistics series.
- The 4 May 1996 date is what the text set, not a record of what followed.
Questions readers ask
Is UN General Assembly Resolution 194 binding on Israel?
The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated in November 2007, as Israel’s own position, that General Assembly resolutions on political matters “do not create legally binding obligations.” It described paragraph 11 as one that “merely recommends” return.
How does Israel read the right to return in human rights treaties?
The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated in 2007 that the principle of return in human rights treaties “only deals with individuals (not an entire people)”. In Israel’s own stated reading, governments have, as a rule, limited re-entry “to nationals of that state.”
Does the 2001 law cover descendants of refugees?
The Entrenchment Law states in section 1 that a refugee includes “a member of his family” (unofficial translation). Israel’s own statute applies the definition to anyone who left Israel’s borders because of war and is not an Israeli citizen.
Does the 2001 law cover people displaced in 1967?
The Entrenchment Law states that its definition includes “the 1967 displaced and the 1948 refugees” (unofficial translation). Both displacements fall under the section 2 rule.
How many Knesset votes would a return need?
The Entrenchment Law states that return requires the approval of “a majority of the Members of the Knesset” (unofficial translation). The text sets no number of refugees and no quota.
Can an Israeli government agree to return in a peace agreement?
The Entrenchment Law states in section 4 that the Government of Israel shall not undertake or enter into an agreement contradicting the law (unofficial translation). This is Israel’s own statutory bar on the executive.
Is the 2001 law a Basic Law?
The Knesset published it in Sefer HaChukim 1772 as an ordinary law. Its text carries no entrenched-majority clause for its own amendment.
Does the 2001 law affect Jewish immigration?
The Entrenchment Law states in section 5 that it does not apply to anyone covered by the Law of Return, 5710-1950. Immigration under that law falls outside it.
Did Oslo II settle the refugee question?
The Oslo II Agreement states in Article XXXI(5) that refugees are among the issues for permanent status negotiations. Article XXXI(6) provides that neither party waived “any of its existing rights, claims or positions.”
Who handled refugee matters under Oslo II?
The Oslo II Agreement states in Article XVII(1) that “Palestinian refugees” are excluded from the Palestinian Council’s jurisdiction. The same list excludes Jerusalem, settlements and borders.
How many people became Israeli citizens automatically in 1952?
The Ministry of Justice records that about 95% of the population then living in Israel, about 1.5 million people, acquired citizenship automatically on 14 July 1952. The figures are the Ministry’s own, drawn from 1952 press reports.
When did Israel first define who its citizens are?
The Ministry of Justice records that the Citizenship Law entered into force on 14 July 1952 and applied retroactively to the day the State was established. From 1948 to 1952, Israel had no legal determination of its citizens.
How many humanitarian residence permits has Israel issued to refugees?
The Ministry of the Interior publishes no count of permits issued under section 3 of the 2001 law. No Israeli body publishes its own count of rules set or permits granted under that section.
Sources
- Israel and the PLO, 1995. The Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (Oslo II). Signed at Washington DC, 28 September 1995. English text as published by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, https://www.gov.il/en/Departments/General/the-israeli-palestinian-interim-agreement. Official or primary record.
- Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2007. Israel, the Conflict and Peace: Answers to frequently asked questions, updated November 2007. gov.il, https://www.gov.il/en/pages/israel-the-conflict-and-peace-answers-to-frequently-asked-questions. Official or primary record, Israel’s own stated legal position.
- Knesset, 2001. Entrenchment of the Rejection of the Right of Return Law, 5761-2001. Sefer HaChukim 1772, 10 January 2001, p. 116, https://fs.knesset.gov.il//15/law/15_lsr_300315.pdf. Official or primary record, Hebrew.
- Ministry of Justice of Israel, 2019. The Citizenship Law, 5712-1952. Roots in Law project, https://www.gov.il/he/Departments/publications/reports/roots_1952. Official or primary record, Hebrew.

